If you're an avid reader, as am I, then you've had that friend who exclaimed, "Oh, you just HAVE to read the book! It's soooo much better than the movie!" 9 times out of 10 I completely agree with their opinion. The books usually are "sooooo" much better than the movies, however, there is that rare story that is simply better when it is seen (or heard) in real life.
1. GAME OF THRONES
Utterly fantastic story. There are no two ways around that one, but if mountains of details are not your thing then skip this book and head straight to your HBO channel or borrow the disks from a friend because the show is absolutely worth seeing. Everyone I know who read the books pictured characters and details in exactly the same way as I did- which is both good and bad. Scenes were so thoroughly described that there was no mistaking what George Martin was trying to convey- good point. In some instances, the amount of detail (though thorough and beautiful) bogged me down and became a bit much to take in- bad point. Some people may not feel the same way, but I had to take this book in small chunks because it was a bit too much to absorb in long sittings. Not to mention there are about a thousand characters you have to keep straight. The easiest way to get through it was to watch an episode of the show and then go back and read until I had caught up. I didn't read beyond the first book, so I can't say whether this would work for everything that followed, but the show stayed amazingly true to the first story (almost word-for-word at parts). I honestly couldn't point out anything you would miss by just watching the episodes on TV (aside from lots and lots of visualizing details and maybe a little character development). If you're a Song of Ice and Fire fan, I'm sorry for raining on your parade.
2. HARRY POTTER AND THE SORCERER'S STONE
Having already seen the movie, I came to this book with great enthusiasm. Many friends of mine were Harry potter nuts (and I mean that in the nicest way possible). The series came highly recommended, so I took an afternoon of sitting at Barnes and Noble and sipping on a hazelnut latte to read the book. The impression I came away with was a wonderful story that had been perfectly replicated on the screen. Now, I am not the type of person who can sit down and tell you all the minute details that were either portrayed or written incorrectly for the screen, but from what I could tell the movie director had done an excellent job of staying true to the story. Sadly, the writing style was juvenile at best because it had been intended for children- not adults. The rest of the series was much better written and Rowling's style evolved as she went, but you aren't missing anything by skipping the first book entirely. If you've seen the movie, start with Chamber of Secrets.
3. THE LORD OF THE RINGS
Details, and details, and more details! Don't get me wrong... I honestly believe that Tolkien gave us an unparalleled gift when he wrote The Lord of the Rings, and many people are probably shocked that I listed it here, but Tolkien took such painstaking care of explaining Frodo's journey that I found myself almost shaking with anxiety while trying to hurry the story along. For the same reasons I found Game of Thrones to be a heavy read, Lord of the Rings also fits the bill. The language Tolkien used also flirts with a hint of Old English which can be a struggle to read in and of itself. While the movies are phenomenal and I've watched them at least 50 times each, there are very important sections of the book that were left out in the interest of time, I'm sure. If details are your thing, then this is the book for you. I don't regret reading it (I say "it" because I own the three-in-one version instead of the individual books), but it was a bit heavier than I had anticipated and I found it less enjoyable than the movies. Also, the music score absolutely MADE the movie, but more on that in a bit.
4. THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA
Speaking of music! When the trailers for the new movie of The Phantom of the Opera came out while I was in high school, I decided I needed to read the book first... because that's the responsible thing for a college-bound student to do, right? For a book that was written around the turn of the century, it was surprisingly enjoyable. Leroux goes into greater detail of the phantom's history and painful childhood which was captivating, however Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical rendition brought me to tears! The movie is a tad long (though not as long as seeing it live on Broadway due to the intermission) but there is no replacement for the music. The story without "The Music of the Night" is nothing more than a mere story.
5. WICKED
This book was one I picked up at Hasting's on a 4 for $5 deal. It made for an extraordinary musical, so I figured the book would be amazing as well. The thing I missed most? The music. Oh, the music! The story is still there (obviously, since that's what the musical was based off) but the writing felt very blah with loads of conversations about seemingly important topics that vanish in the next chapter and turn out to be nothing. I know people who have read the book and tell me they enjoyed it, but I struggled. If someone asks my opinion on this one... just see the musical.
6. SEX AND THE CITY
Watched it... LOVED it... read it... felt a little let down. If you've seen the show and fallen in love with Carrie and her friends then reading the book leaves you feeling a little, "Wait, where's the rest of the story?" There is surprisingly little mention of the main characters we know and love, and while reading the book woke up my inner creative voice and inspired me to do a little writing of my own, I found there to be very little of an actual story line. Mostly, the book is random encounters with random fabulous people and their conversations. While an exhilarating read, if you come to it looking for the show you'll be let down. The book felt completely different. Bushnell's writing style kept me engaged and the book was a very fast, very entertaining read, but it's not the story from the show. Come to it, enjoy it for what it is, and that's that.
7. THE HUNT FOR RED OCTOBER
I believe it takes a certain kind of person (probably with a military background) to enjoy Clancy's writing style. That person is obviously not me. After seeing the movie, I found the book on a clearance rack and decided to give it a go. I figured that knowing the movie's plot would help me keep the story straight in my head while I read- this trick worked wonders for me later when I was reading Game of Thrones. Sadly, the cut and dry story laced with military jargon and dry characters left me appreciating the movie even more. In all honesty, I made it- maybe- a quarter of the way through the book and had to put it down. It was simply too dry for my taste. Love the movie, though!
8. THE TIME TRAVELER'S WIFE
"The book where nothing much happens," is what I would have entitled this one. In the grand scheme of things, the story is beautiful: a woman falls in love with a man tortured by uncontrollable time travel, and she suffers a life with a man who unwillingly comes and goes. It has all the makings of a great movie. The book, on the other hand, felt like a lot of waiting. There was nothing difficult about the read, but not a whole lot happens over the 500+ pages. While muddling through the boring interior, I kept thinking, "It's going to get better. It HAS to get better. They made a movie out of it for crying out loud!" My male doctor walked in for my appointment and happened to see the book laying on the counter. "How are you liking it so far?" he asked, and I had to be honest... I was bored. He laughed, "Yeah, I felt the same way about it. It doesn't get any better, either." I was less than 100 pages from the end, I knew what ultimately happened, so I threw in the towel. Great idea. Great movie. Less than stellar book. If you get an itching to read it you're more than welcome to my copy- KEEP IT.
9. A WALK TO REMEMBER
I know I'm probably alone in this, but Sparks' writing style had me wishing for more. And, this isn't the only book of his I didn't care for... I own several because I keep telling myself that maybe I'll like the next one. Just as it had with The Time Traveler's Wife, the overall story had me hooked, however the writing style didn't impress me in the least. The book is short, it was easy to read, and yet I didn't enjoy it at all. Again, it's probably just me. There hasn't been a Nicholas Sparks movie that I HAVEN'T bawled my way through, and yet the books always seem to fall flat in comparison. It's nothing I can stick a pin to and say this is the culprit... I just don't care for the written versions of his stories.
Please visit my website www.AshleyGesslerSHD.com |